The collegiate esports scene is facing heated backlash after Sheldon (Sheldoin), the Assistant Director at Winthrop University and Esports GM at CCG Esports, was called out for handling a recruitment conversation with shocking insensitivity.
Screenshots of the Discord conversation surfaced online, showing how a player known as Toad expressed interest in joining Winthrop's esports program but shared his financial struggles.
"I am paying for college myself... having to pay a $50 application fee without knowing if Winthrop is the school for me is a tight situation that I don't wish to put myself in."
Instead of offering understanding or guidance, Sheldon responded coldly:
"Unfortunately can't do that for you... $50 is a drop in the bucket."
Toad's respectful request for a fee waiver was quickly shut down, leaving many in the community disappointed by how a university figurehead treated a student struggling to afford higher education.
Toad later issued a statement criticizing the interaction:
"Unacceptable behavior from what is supposed to be a leader in collegiate esports. If we want our competitions to be taken seriously, we need to start acting like professionals. A football coach would never speak to a recruit like this. Remember that YOU reached out to ME."
Prominent esports personalities like Ovilee May stepped in to show support:
"This is incredibly unprofessional from that manager... If you need help with purchasing school supplies once you hit college please let me know 😊"
Sheldon later issued a public apology:
"I want to apologize to @AU_Toad. I understand that this is not the correct way to speak to students/recruits. I promise to be better moving forward."
However, the apology has done little to quell the outrage, with many calling for greater accountability from those in leadership positions in collegiate esports. The situation has sparked larger conversations about the power dynamics between students and staff — and whether esports programs are upholding the same standards of professionalism seen in traditional college athletics.
Comments